Someone just emailed asking whether JDate is as bad as I make it sound. Yes. From female friends on JDate I've heard a number of horror stories, all of which entail an arrogant guy feeling entitled and treating them badly. My experience on JDate is that the women are fiercely practical, to a barbaric degree in my mind, about their dating lives. It is heartless to me and I had to leave - it was giving me a very unhealthy view of women.
Here's the problem at its core. Jewish women, on JDate anyway, are generally looking for a Jewish man to raise Jewish children with. Jewish men, like all men, are looking for sex and love. I don't think too many men put having children higher on the list than the sex and love. Not all women do either, but woman strike me as far more practical about love than men. Men just love. We don't care what your salary is or whether you've found your path in life yet. We're happy to love you along the way.
So, imagine you're a Jewish male. When I meet an attractive Jewish girl, I find some way to get it out there that I'm Jewish within about half a minute. Usually this isn't difficult, as the young woman is trying to derive this information pretty actively on her own (well, if I'm lucky - if she's not attracted to me this is all out the window). It's a bit tacky to simply ask, but Jewish culture provides a billion ways to get it out there in casual conversation through some kind of joke.
Now, still imagining you're a Jewish male, pretend you are presented with two hot young women, one of whom is Jewish, the other not, and both of them seem to want to jump your bones. Which is scarier? To me it's the one I know for a fact is looking for someone to drive their kids to Sunday school. Not that non-Jewish women are only looking for fun - obviously that's not true - and not that Jewish women aren't looking for fun - everyone is - but for most Jewish women around 30, on JDate anyway, there is an agenda and there is little time for distraction.
So now imagine a website where the one thing you know about (almost) everyone is that they're Jewish. So you have guys that know that being Jewish gives them huge points, nearly unbeatable points, with a Jewish woman (at least over non-Jewish men, drastically reducing the pool of competition), and women that are highly motivated to make things work, to the point that they'll pay 40 bucks a month for it - $10-15 more than any other site. (Although many women just hide their email or IM name in their profile knowing that guys will go the extra mile and write to them if she's cute enough. Guys cannot get away with this - to a girl he's cheap. Although even there, the best relationship I got out of JDate was months after I cancelled my account but had left my email address hidden backwards in my profile and a girl emailed me out of the blue. The girl of my dreams will most likely contact (or approach) me first).
One unfortunate result of all this earnestness and such high stakes is that all the profiles (female anyway; I haven't read the male profiles) are nearly identical. They're all living life to the fullest, they all try to get the most out of the city that it has to offer, they all love to laugh (does anyone not like to laugh?), they're all silly but sometimes serious, they're all close with their families (this may be uniquely Jewish, I don't know - most Jews are fairly close with their families), they all love to go dancing but can also make it a Blockbuster night, and many, many of them begin their profiles with "I am" and then a list of adjectives, almost invariably smart, silly, serious, full of energy, ambitious, caring. Hello! McFly! Show, don't tell! You wouldn't tolerate that bland bullshit from a guy's profile. Also, many of them, for reasons I can only guess at, state that they're cute, attractive, sexy, beautiful, something along those lines. I'm looking at your picture for god's sake, what are you telling me?
The other unfortunate result from what friends tell me is that many guys on JDate behave in person like assholes. One of my friend's dates left before they sat down for coffee because he wasn't attracted to her. I hate that guy - really hurt my friend's feelings. Another, a doctor, ended the date with a friend of mine by standing up and saying "I recommend you delineate some goals for yourself", and left. Who do these dicks think they are?
Goal-oriented dating, and hence JDate, is a recipe for disaster.
I recommend nerve.com though - most people there are much more chill and willing to get to know new people regardless of the outcome. Much healthier and much more fun for everybody. And I'll bet many more happy relationships come of it.
Though nothing beats meeting naturally in person. It trumps everything.